Readjusting to life in the Legislature in mid-summer is much like returning to college after taking five years off. Nevertheless, the business of the state is finally being attended to.
The spirit in the Unicameral is more combative this summer than ever before. Besides the barrage of personal attacks, recent events concerning the coronavirus, protests in the streets, and the movement to defund our police departments, coupled with the need for property tax relief have led to some very spirited and passionate floor debates.
Early in the week Sen. Geist led a successful pull motion to put her anti-dismembership abortion bill, LB 814, on General File against the wishes of the Judiciary committee.
This is a bill that should have been voted out of the Judiciary Committee for the simple reason that it already had 25 total sponsors and 30 senators voted to pull it.
Last Thursday, Sen. Justin Wayne of Omaha led a successful movement to suspend the rules of the Legislature in order to allow him to introduce a new bill.
The rules of the Legislature limit the introduction of new bills to the first 10 days of the legislative session. Wayne’s new bill would require cities to create citizen oversight committees over their police departments, which I do not agree with.
The Revenue Committee’s property tax relief bill, LB 1106, failed to advance.
This bill offers some property tax relief, but not as much as my resolution last year for a constitutional amendment for the 35% solution or my resolution this year for a constitutional amendment to replace our current tax code with a single-rate consumption tax.
Another bill that failed to advance last week was LB 720, the ImagiNE Nebraska Act. The ImagiNE Nebraska Act was designed to replace the Nebraska Advantage Act, which is set to sunset later this year.
However, these kinds of tax incentive programs have no measurable track record of success. The proponents of this bill were hard pressed to name a single business that moved to Nebraska because of the Nebraska Advantage Act.
Instead, these programs provide businesses with millions of dollars in tax credits, which results in loss of revenue for our cities. Moreover, when these businesses get their sales taxes refunded back to them through the program, it is the cities who have to flip the bill. When cities have to pay the bill, property taxes go up. Nebraska does not need these kinds of business welfare programs.
Last Wednesday, Speaker Scheer put LB 1106 on the agenda before LB 720. This was intentional because several senators had said they would not vote for the ImagiNE Nebraska Act unless property tax relief was passed first.
Because property tax relief failed to advance, support for the ImagiNE Nebraska Act dwindled and the bill failed to advance.
Passing the ImagiNE Nebraska Act at the same time as property tax relief would have undermined our efforts to get property tax relief altogether and made our situation even worse. For instance, if you receive $60,000 in property tax relief, but your total taxes go up $120,000, you end up with a net loss of $60,000. This is the kind of twisted logic that followed the plan to pass both of these bills.
The battles are far from over.
In the remaining days of the legislative session, you should expect to see senators attempt to amend their bad bills into other bills, creating Christmas tree bills. Christmas tree bills are bills that contain other bill amended into it.
Moreover, you should expect to see more senators move to suspend the rules and introduce even more bills. This happened again on Friday when Sen. Vargas of Omaha moved to suspend the rules again.
Hopefully, the personal attacks will cease.
In a nutshell, let me just say that the final days of the 106th Legislature are shaping up to look very much like a trip to Omaha’s Henry Doorly Zoo.
Steve Erdman represents Dist. 47 — west of Lincoln County — in the state legislature. His district includes the towns of Ogallala and Sidney.