Content on this page requires a newer version of Adobe Flash Player.

Get Adobe Flash player

Log In or Register
HomeLocal NewsState NewsSportsOpinionObituariesAgriculture
Quick Links
  Home
  My Bulletin
  Contact The Bulletin

Marketplace
  Display Ads
  Classifieds
  Dir. of Advertisers

Opinion

At the Legislature: So long from Tom Hansen

At the Legislature: Fire fighting, water in reservoirs

More opinion

Ag News

Legislature eases farm equipment shipping

Winter: 27th coldest, 18th driest

More Ag News


Email Article | Print Article
News - State/Regional News
 
Bill would ban minors from tanning Tell North Platte what you think
 

In an emotionally charged hearing Friday, Nebraska legislators listened to supporters and opponents of the Skin Cancer Prevention Act.

NebraskaLand National BankYou've got a
facebook Request!
CLICK HERE!

If passed, the law would ban anyone younger than 18 from using indoor tanning beds at salons.

“This is truly a matter of life and death and deserves our attention and action,” the act’s sponsor Sen. Jeremy Nordquist of Omaha said.

Nordquist said he introduced the measure because it’s a public health crisis. He cited the rise of cases of skin cancer among young women who use tanning beds as the reason for the legislation.

Proponent David Holmquist, a lobbyist for the Cancer Action Network and skin cancer survivor himself, said his organization stopped handing out sunscreen because it made people feel that it provided enough protection to tan safely.

“Tanning bed use raises the risk of melanoma by 75 percent,” Holmquist said, adding that studies show sunscreen rated at SPF 45 provide insufficient protection.

Opponent Barton Bonn of Omaha, owner of the Ashley Lynn’s Tanning franchise, said his chain preaches to tan safely.

“The key is not to burn,” he said.

Bonn said being tan is not a dangerous standard of beauty if it’s done safely by using the right time in the tanning bed.

“Without sunburning, it’s a very healthy standard,” he said. “[Without tanning] you’re likely to be vitamin D deficient.”


Saving young girls

Dr. David Watts, an Omaha dermatologist, disagreed.

“There’s no controversy, but there is spin,” he said. “You can get a melanoma without ever getting a burn,” Watts said.

As for obtaining vitamin D, bill proponent Dr. Stacie Bleicher, a Lincoln pediatrician, said getting it from food or from supplements was inexpensive and safer.

Bonn said this piece of strict legislation, where allowing a person under 18 to tan would result in a Class V misdemeanor, would be used to eventually close down tanning salons everywhere. He said people younger than 18 make up 5 percent of Ashley Lynn’s clientele.

“I’d hate to see our industry cut off,” he said.

But supporter of the ban Jessica Guerrero, 26, a melanoma skin cancer survivor who started tanning at age 14, said this is not about closing tanning salons. She said that wasn’t necessary.

“[This is about] saving young girls’ lives,” she said.

Guerrero, a registered nurse, said that since her diagnosis when she was 24, she has to think about the disease all the time. She listed constant doctor’s appointments, being immunocompromised, and wearing sunscreen as measures that require more thought.

“If I’m driving in my car, I have sunscreen on,” she said.

For medical reasons, opponent Deb Davis said she doesn’t want legislators telling her how to parent. She said she and her children have used tanning beds to cope with eczema and it has helped.

She said tanning has also helped avoid the financial burden of seeing a dermatologist.

“For the financial cost, I don’t know what else we would do,” she said.

According to a 2011 survey by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 21 percent of all high school girls report having used indoor tanning beds and tanning salon patrons “tend to be young, non-Hispanic white women.”

In a tearful testimony, proponent Kasey Shriver, 21, said teens don’t understand the risks of tanning. Shriver was diagnosed with melanoma when she was 17. She started tanning three years earlier to prepare for a trip to Hawaii.

"I would like to say I live life with no regrets, but using that tanning bed for the first time when I was 14 will forever be my biggest regret," she said.


Like this story to send to your facebook

The North Platte Bulletin - Published 1/26/2013
Copyright © 2013 northplattebulletin.com - All rights reserved.
Flatrock Publishing, Inc. - 1300 E 4th St., Suite F - North Platte, NE 69101
 
Show me Talk Back during this visit
 
 

Copyright © 2003 - 2014 northplattebulletin.com
All rights reserved.

Flatrock Publishing, Inc.
1300 E 4th St., Suite F
North Platte, NE 69101

 
Your Ip Address - 107.21.163.227
North Platte, Nebraska